Mothering against motherhood: doula work, xenohospitality and the idea of the momrade

Abstract

Today, a new vein of queer Marxist-feminist family-abolitionist theorising is reviving contemporary feminists willingness to imagine, politically, what women's liberationists in the 1970s called “mothering against motherhood”. Concurrently, the jokey portmanteau “momrade”, i.e., mom + comrade, has circulated persistently in the twenty-first century on online forums maintained by communities of mothers and/or leftists. This article asks: what if, in the name of abolishing the family, we took the joke entirely seriously? What makes a “mom” a “momrade”, or vice versa? In what ways does the work of reproduction, conceivably, actively participate in class struggles, producing new worlds (and un-producing others)? How do the collective arts of mothering unmake selves? And how does the verb “to mother” work to abolish the present state of things? The chosen point of departure for exploring these questions is the concept of xenohospitality; a term I borrow from Helen Hester – one of the authors of the Xenofeminist Manifesto – who defines it as openness to the alien, a definition I link closely to “comradeliness”. Further, the meaning of the term “family abolition”, here, is aptly summed up by the formula “xenofam ≥ biofam”; to abolish the family is not to destroy relationships of care and nurturance, but on the contrary, to expand and proliferate them. Reflecting on the conditions of possibility for such universally xenofamilial – that is to say, comradely – kin relations, this article implicitly argues for utopia(nism) in feminist kinship studies. It grounds this utopianism, however, in first-hand experiences of informal “death doula” labour. The labour of mothering one's mother is offered as a potential practice of un-mothering oneself and others. In fact, the argument pivots on these auto-ethnographic observations about maternal bereavement, because the event of the author's mother's death interrupted and intruded upon the feminist theorising involved.